David dressed for his presentation.
Traditionally a fish pie is made with smoked salmon and smoked haddock, cooked in a cheese sauce and topped with mashed potatoes. There was quite a stir when Dennis claimed to have put crab and monk fish in his pie but the monk fish did suit his presentation as he dressed up in a homemade monk outfit and recited the biblical version of how the fish pie was created...it was a really great presentation. Another ongoing debate is the use of hard boiled eggs in the fish pie, not really a traditional ingredient and one that David uses every year despite protests and jeers from the other competitors. In the end there was a huge upset as John Garden won the contest. He used a recipe from Jamie Oliver's cookbook (which is allowed), had a great presentation which was an Ode to Sandy Callander (David's father who had just passed away), and served the judges his pie in a waiter's uniform and served sorbet to cleanse their pallets. But, as all of Scotland knows, it's John Garden who has never been allowed to win even if he has the greatest pie on the planet simply because he's John Garden! But he won and will bask in the glory of the winner's circle until next time. David had a really great presentation as well, concocting a story about how the hard boiled egg was introduced to the fish pie via military presence in the Middle East.
David's Fish Pie (with stolen parsley)
(A startling and upseting 2nd place finish.)
John's Fish Pie
(This year's champion.)
Bruce's Fish Pie
(3rd place)
Dennis' Fish Pie
(Came in 1st at the last competition but came in 4th place this year.)
The Judges from left to right: Simon, Keith, and Alistair
The Competitors from left to right: Bruce, Dennis, David and John
I know you all have been waiting anxiously for the pictures from the Fish Pie competition so here they are!
I know you all have been waiting anxiously for the pictures from the Fish Pie competition so here they are!